Feature Article
April 2001

 

Bridging The Gap Via IP Fax

BY JUSTIN SMITH

Despite opinions to the contrary, old technologies never die. Instead, they continue to grow in importance and both direct and indirect influence, even in the face of lost novelty. Fax, like book printing and, in fact, all hardcopy document generation, is an "old" technology that continues to grow. Thanks to the ascendancy of IP-based networking and the .tif electronic fax file format, fax is no longer tied exclusively to the hard-copy document generation. On the contrary, fax often bridges the gap in important socio-economic interactions that now require both hardcopy and electronic document distribution, particularly when distribution requirements cannot be anticipated in advance.

With this in mind, it should come as no surprise that fax continues to grow both in terms of adoption (it is estimated that up to 80 percent of commercial sites do not yet have even a rudimentary LAN fax server capability) and total pages transmitted. As a result, its influence on related technologies, increasingly inter-related technology "bundles" (i.e. "convergence"), and associated converged application market development also continues to grow.

WHY FAX IS STILL IMPORTANT
Fax isn't going away any faster than paper is going away. For decades, corporate soothsayers have been predicting something called "the paperless office." Truth be told, we deal with more paper than ever before. It is true that the core of each new business process introduced or converted to a Web interface tends to depend less and less on paper and more and more on Web technology, that particular paper-reducing effect tends to be outweighed by the sheer volume of transaction growth. Transactions are growing at such a staggering pace that older paper-based processes get pulled along.

Fax is also still the chosen (and sometimes required) means of transmission for documents such as legal contracts, invoices, and so on. One of the little-known secrets of e-commerce is that many of the back office operations and behind-the-scenes order fulfillment processes transpiring between e-commerce companies and their suppliers and partners are still very much fax-based. Behind a single Web-based consumer purchase may lurk three or four faxes.

Although many core transaction processes are becoming paperless, many peripheral processes remain stubbornly paper-oriented. For example, we may book concert tickets online, but hardcopy proof of the transaction (the tickets), is still required for admission to the concert. When we place orders for products over the Web, typically we print a hardcopy of the transaction receipt, including lengthy order-tracking numbers, for our records. Even when we book "electronic" airline tickets, the wise traveler usually prints out a hardcopy of the travel itinerary originally e-mailed to them by their travel agent. When we return home from a business trip, we submit paper receipts as proof of our travel expenses. Thanks to the security risks inherent with electronic systems, this situation is unlikely to change in the foreseeable future.

NEW MESSAGING APPLICATIONS
Precisely because fax straddles the gulf between electronic and hardcopy transactions, we find that fax lies at the heart of new electronic messaging systems. Unified messaging applications, call center applications, and the like retain fax capabilities, at least as a back-stop to other, more cutting-edge Web and digital voice recording-based processes.

Yet fax isn't thought of as a sexy technology. To do fax right, with high rates of reliability (i.e. first-attempt connection success, call completion, optimal-throughput) is not as easy as many technology providers think. Customers, meanwhile, expect any unified messaging application (to name just one example of converged communications applications), to include a robust faxing capability. How often have we heard end-users say, "It isn't unified messaging if it doesn't do fax."

Because fax, the "old" technology, often gets the least attention when tying together converged applications, it is frequently the weakest link in the converged communications chain. Occasionally, this sine qua non of converged messaging can even lead to a customer's rejection of an entire converged application.

WHAT ABOUT IP?
On a parallel path, as we all know IP is fast becoming the de facto standard, without an apparent peer, for all kinds of digitized content distribution, whether underpinning the public data network, private (managed) data networks, or corporate or site-specific networks. Most industry observers expect some evolved form of IP packet switching to gradually supplant all circuit switching in the PSTN and elsewhere.

It is true that competing (or otherwise complementary) ATM technology lies at the core of many high-bandwidth switching systems and at the heart of many carrier networks, but the dream of end-to-end Quality of Service (QoS) capabilities based on ATM may never be fully realized due to the high cost of equipping end stations. In the meantime, IP continues to evolve as an all-purpose transport technology without being encumbered by specific ties to high-cost hardware at the end points of the transaction.

Twenty-five years from now, the familiar LAN vs. WAN technology distinctions, which were ultimately based on differences in underlying transmission technology and available bandwidth, will no longer apply. It will be impossible to distinguish between public and private networking on the basis of the underlying switching technology used.

Just as IP is evolving to transform the basis of all networks, public and private, fax in its own way serves as a common denominator for converged messaging applications. Together, the two technologies will exert an influence on each other and on other messaging types and communication media in the evolution of both public and private networks and associated converged communications applications. As fax is tied to IP, it will also bring along other message types to IP-based networks and associated applications, and vice versa.

WHAT ABOUT FAX OVER IP?
Ironically, technologies often reach the zenith of their influence at precisely the point when their universality becomes either old news or otherwise undetectable to the end user. To a degree, this has already transpired with fax over IP (FoIP) and voice over IP (VoIP) technologies.

The early impetus behind FoIP and VoIP implementations as a means for individuals, small businesses, and enterprises to by-pass high telco tariff rates has largely faded, especially in the United States, because long-distance rates have come down substantially. This has happened for a number of reasons, including the advent of FoIP and VoIP technologies themselves. Thanks to reduced telco rates, the savings associated with classical FoIP and VoIP are no longer substantial enough for the average, already overwhelmed IT department to bother overcoming the not-insubstantial technical hurdles associated with rolling out a satisfactory system.

As a result, real-time FoIP implementations have largely become a non-issue. However, this does not mean that FoIP is unimportant. In fact, it means the opposite. Fax is now an indispensable part of larger messaging systems.

Meanwhile, the flexibility of IP in enabling any kind of messaging type has simply stolen the show. Fax service providers, for example, no longer concentrate on providing fax services, but on providing IP based services of all kinds.

This second phase of development, when FoIP and VoIP technologies become inextricably linked with the underlying public networks and service providers, will pave the way for a future phase of IP and IP-based application adoption in the enterprise. The on ramps for enterprises to link their in-house IP messaging systems are being built now. And as we have seen already, corporations will be unwilling to outsource their most sensitive communications functions. Hence, we will always see a mix of both hosted and in-house applications.

NEW TECHNOLOGIES AND FAX
Although recent adjustments in the financial sector have reduced near-term development prospects for the telecom sector, mobile computing, communications, and technologies that enable various devices to interact with each other, will continue to evolve.

For example, imagine the opportunities for faxing opened up by handheld devices. The occasional need for hardcopies in addition to exact electronic reproductions provided by electronic .tif files will always be with us. What will we do when we receive a fax as a .tif file in our unified messaging in-box accessible from our mobile phone, but our screen is either too small to view the document, or we are speaking to someone who is not equipped with a similar device or service, but would like to provide them with a hardcopy of the fax?

Handheld messaging services will naturally create additional need for the occasional, or perhaps even frequent, hardcopy print out. If we can forward the fax received from our mobile phone handset to a nearby fax machine, either via the public network or via other, local peer-to-peer wireless technologies such as Bluetooth, our need is satisfied.

CONCLUSION
All in all, the dynamic, self-reinforcing interplay between and evolution of the various networks, media, and messaging types that exist today will create a world of opportunity for end-users, corporate IT departments, and service providers alike. The next 25 years should be very interesting. And some evolved form of fax technology will still remain with us as an integral and necessary part of communications systems.

Justin Smith is product marketing manager for Brooktrout Technology. For more information, please visit www.brooktrout.com.

[ Return To The April 2001 Table Of Contents ]