Analytical Views
June 2001

Brian Strachman LAN Telephony: What's The Point?

BY BRIAN STRACHMAN


As an analyst, I am frequently asked to explain the merits of new technologies and products. For the past several years I have been one of the strongest proponents of LAN telephony, which is the technology and market segment in which enterprise telephone calls are transmitted via the local area network (LAN) instead of using telephone wiring and a PBX. It's a very cool technology with many great reasons to implement it. However, the best motivators are not what you might imagine.

To better demonstrate this point, I thought I'd share with you an example of a typical dialogue I have had on dozens of occasions with both end users and the press:

End user: Wow! You mean we only have to have a single wire to the desktop?

Me: Yes, but that's not really the most compelling reason to buy it. There are a variety of reasons, not the least of which is price. Most LAN telephony systems are at least 30 percent cheaper than the PBX alternative.

End user: I don't buy into any of those pricing statistics. Statistics can be made to show anything, 87 percent of all people know that!

Me: Well, don't forget about administration. Moves, adds, and changes are all done using a simple graphical interface. In fact, you can just unplug your IP phone, walk down the hall and plug it in somewhere else and it will work. This will save you thousands in maintenance costs from the PBX company.

End user: I rarely have my people move offices or change extensions. That's not really a big deal to me.

Me: Far and away the biggest reason is the applications! By using IP technology in the handsets, it is an ideal environment for new applications that are not possible using circuit-switched environment. LAN telephony lets you do things you simply can't do with a standard network. It's the applications that are the real motivator, and the best reason to go with LAN telephony.

End user: Sounds great. What kind of applications are you talking about?

Me: Well, umm, lot's of great apps. They're just not here yet... but they will be!

The Time Is Now
And that's where the conversation usually takes a downturn. LAN telephony offers a great technical environment for some really innovative applications. It's just that they haven't been built yet. I've always believed that it's the applications, not the technology, that truly drives a new product, but the better the technology the better the app. It was only a matter of time before we saw cool apps and the market really takes off. That time is finally here.

I recently spoke with Cisco, one of the leaders in LAN telephony, and they mentioned they recently had a developers' showcase and gave out awards for the most compelling applications. I'm not going to mention names of vendors here because these products are still preliminary and untested, but I thought I'd share some of the applications. I believe they are important to the LAN telephony market as a whole.

Room-To-Room Text Messaging
This is a great app targeted at the hospitality industry. It lets users send text messages from room to room, thus greatly freeing up hotel operators' time and giving guests a more efficient way to schedule things like wake up calls, check out times, and dinner reservations.

Time-Of-Day Routing
This app, designed for the K-12 market, lets specific calls go to specific phones based on the time of day. For the worried parent, this application means that by dialing one number the system can query a student's schedule and route the call immediately to the appropriate classroom. Knowing how overly worried some parents are, this app would have to be used with great discretion.

Conference Room Scheduling
Both for the hospitality industry and the enterprise, this app eliminates the headache of overbooking conference rooms and can even automatically forward calls.

User-Administered Routing
Not to forget the call center, this app lets the user define basic routing and hunt groups right from the desktop. For the small call center, proper call routing can mean the difference between success and failure.

Training
The average PBX has over 500 different features and most users don't know more than three. I know I still tell callers to hang on and not be surprised if I drop them during call transfers. This app is a set of training exercises designed to help the user get the most from their phone. Ideally the IP handset will be easier to use than its PBX cousin, but training is still necessary and often overlooked.

Driving The Market
These are just a few examples of applications that are only possible with the use of LAN telephony. Through Cisco's developer program, these apps will be brought to market over the next year. However, this is simply the first step, signaling future products yet to come.

LAN telephony is the right technology for enterprise voice, yet it is still up to the developers to create them. And my typical response when asked what these great applications will be that will create a billion dollar market? "If I knew what these great applications were, I'd quit my job and start a company producing them. I just know they're coming."

Brian Strachman is senior analyst, Voice and Data Communications, Cahners In-Stat Group. To correspond with the author, please send your comments to brians@instat.com.

[ Return To The June 2001 Table Of Contents ]